Hiring Holds Its Breath: Small Employers Wait on Jobs Day and New SBA Rules
Small-business hiring is positive but slowing, with fewer owners recruiting and most struggling to find qualified applicants. The SBA's rewritten loan rulebook took effect yesterday, just as the September jobs report lands.
Key Trends
-
Update: the last brief called small-employer hiring flat; two more September gauges say it is positive but cooling. Gusto’s data shows small businesses added 28,000 net jobs in September, the eighth straight monthly gain, but below the 12-month average of 34,000 after August was revised down to 18,500.
-
Owners are pulling back on recruiting: NFIB found 51% of owners hired or tried to hire in September, down 5 points from August, and 45% reported few or no qualified applicants. Weak demand and a thin talent pool are squeezing growth from both sides.
-
The gauges disagree on direction but agree on tone. Paychex’s index, covered last brief, showed headcount flat; Gusto’s shows gains slower than trend; NFIB’s shows fewer owners trying to hire at all. Taken together, small employers are holding payroll steady rather than expanding it, and the reluctance is showing up in intent before it shows up in layoffs.
Notable Businesses & Launches
No significant developments today.
Funding & Investment
No significant developments today. The only SMB-focused round surfaced this week, Mona’s $3.5M, was covered in the previous brief.
Regulatory & Economic Context
-
Update: the SBA’s SOP 50 10 8.1 took effect October 1, as the last brief anticipated. Forbes characterizes the 416-page rewrite as more paperwork and less lending, with the aim of lowering default rates. Early lender data on approval times will be the thing to watch.
-
Beyond acquisitions, the rewrite touches borrower structure: it reportedly requires a trust to guarantee a loan at any ownership percentage, and a trustor to guarantee personally regardless of whether the trust is revocable. That matters for owners who hold their company in an estate-planning trust.
Unverified
The trust-guarantee detail rests on a single secondary summary of the SOP; confirm against the SBA’s published text.
-
Update: the September jobs report is out at 8:30 a.m. today. Wall Street expected roughly 84,000 jobs and unemployment holding at 4.1%, a step down from August’s 162,000.
Review
“August’s 162,000” — the figure is correct per BLS, but the Bloomberg link is a Sept. 26 forecast piece (“seen showing 90,000 payrolls”), not the August result, and it implies a 90,000 consensus versus the 84,000 cited from CNBC — cite BLS for 162,000 and reconcile the consensus figure.
Unverified
Actual results were not available when this brief was drafted; the figures above are consensus forecasts, not outcomes. Check BLS before relying on them.
Takeaway
Takeaway
Small employers are not cutting, but they have stopped reaching: with demand soft, qualified applicants scarce, and credit about to get slower to obtain, owners are choosing to hold position rather than invest, and a decent headline jobs number would hide that.